Upskilling Expert Witnesses - Individual Modules
For The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)
Being a successful Expert Witness demands more than just having technical knowledge and experience, you need to understand the context and processes imposed upon you by Tribunal expectations and directions. This programme is designed to equip you with these critical skills. This upskilling initiative is designed for mid to senior level valuers and related professionals – anyone who appears as an expert witness in Business Rates, Compulsory Purchase and Telecoms. Whether you are seeking to develop, or fine tune existing skills, the programme is deliberately broad so both emerging and experienced professionals can benefit. Additionally, the programme will also be valuable for solicitors involved in instructing experts with litigation matters.
| Start Date | Venue | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 26 March 2026 | Module 1 (In Person, London): The Art of Gathering and Weighing Evidence, London | ||
| 13 April 2026 | Module 2 (Virtual): Rules, Roles and Responsibilities | ||
| 11 May 2026 | Module 3a (Virtual): Rating in the Valuation Tribunal | ||
| 18 May 2026 | Module 3b (Virtual): The duty for the parties to mediate in CPO disputes | ||
| 8 June 2026 | Module 4:(Virtual) Writing Expert Reports | ||
| 29 June 2026 | Module 5 (Virtual): Practice Directions: Narrowing the Issues to Encourage Early Settlement | ||
| 13 July 2026 | Module 6 (In Person, London): The Hearing, and Lessons from the Front Line |
Note: All prices are to be paid in GBP and are subject to VAT at the prevailing rate
Module Details
- Module 1 - In Person Event: Thursday 26 March. Buy this module on demand here
- Module 2 - Virtual Event: Monday 13 April. Buy this module on demand here
- Module 3a - Virtual Event: Monday 11 May. Buy this module on demand here
- Module 3b - Virtual Event: Monday 18 May. Buy this module on demand here
- Module 4 - Virtual Event: Monday 8 June. Buy this module on demand here
- Module 5 - Virtual Event: Monday 29 June. Buy this module on demand here
- Module 6 - In Person Event: Monday 13 July. CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP, London. Timings: 10:30 - 16:30. This event is followed by a drinks reception
Why This Programme?
- Strong negotiators and valuers don’t automatically make strong expert witnesses. This course will explain responsibilities and assist in adapting from client focused advocacy to impartial commentary to assist the court.
- Junior team members often support expert reports. This programme builds competence and confidence to contribute meaningfully in that role. Equally, these people may be the experts of the future.
- Your first case is the most memorable. This course is designed with that moment in mind, to prepare participants thoroughly for their debut case.
- A library resource when you need it. Few experts are called upon regularly, so it’s important to build skills without the pressure of an imminent court appearance. When those skills aren’t practiced often, procedures can become rusty. With most modules delivered online and fully recorded, you’ll have on-demand access to a library of resources whenever you need a refresher.
- Expert work is team-based…until it’s not. Understanding context and the Tribunal’s role is crucial. While solicitors, counsel and colleagues may help build the case, only the expert signs the report and stands alone in the witness box. The programme seeks to instil confidence in making the critical decisions.
- The courtroom is unforgiving. One biased or unsupported comment can damage your credibility beyond repair. The recent case Patarkatsishvili v Woodward-Fisher [2025] EWHC 265 (Ch) is a reminder of how high the stakes can be. What can we learn from the behaviours of others? The need to avoid giving “grudgingly monosyllabic responses”, see Nofax Station Road Limited V London Borough of Barnet [2025] UKUT 241 (LC).
- Disputes are often negotiated while they’re being prepared for Tribunal. This creates pressure on experts who may also be part of the negotiation team. We’ll explore the boundaries and responsibilities involved and whether this dual role is acceptable.
- Expert work can be isolating. We’ll share 'war stories', lessons learnt the hard way and guidance to help you avoid the same mistakes.
- The need for skilled experts will not fade. Business Rates, Compulsory Purchase and Telecoms work is complex and specialised. So too, their disputes. Experts will always be needed to assist the Tribunal in making its determination.
- This is so much more than CPD. There is no formal assessment. A certificate alone does not make a great expert witness - the value lies in mastering the skills, judgement and professional robustness required to be the “go-to” expert in your field and as seniors in your work the latter is far more motivating. It will be your developing career and those of others that will provide the testimony and value of the programme.
Although each jurisdiction has its own procedural nuances, the underlying anatomy of disputes is well understood. Courts and Tribunals apply established procedures for preparing and presenting cases and the expectations placed on experts (in conduct, evidence, and professionalism) are broadly consistent across forums but are quite different to giving evidence at a public planning inquiry. The rigour with which Judges and Tribunal members assess evidence is similarly ingrained, regardless of sector.
Speakers Confirmed to Date
- Hashi Mohamed, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Dan Kolinsky KC, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Tim Smith, Partner, Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner LLP; Part-Time Judge
- Josh Myerson FRICS Dip Rating IRRV (Hons), Head of Advisory, Montagu Evans LLP; Immediate Past Chair of the Rating Diploma Holders' Section of the RICS
- Hannah Griffin, Managing Director - Disputes, Investigations & Valuations, Quantuma
- Jonathan Stott MRICS, Group Managing Director, Ardent
- Colin Smith, Consultant, Dalcour Maclaren
- Colin Cottage BSc (Hons) MRICS RICS Registered Valuer, Managing Director - Compensation, Ardent
- Kate New, Partner, Foot Anstey LLP
- Luke Wilcox, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Blake Penfold BSc FRICS MCIArb, Business Rates Consultant, Blake Penfold Consultancy
- Wayne Cox FRICS Dip Rating, Head of Leisure and Licensed Property, HMRC Valuation Office
- Colin Hunter, Divisional Director - Rating, CHExpertise Ltd
- Lee Anderson BSc (Hons) IRRV (Hons), Interim Chief Executive, Valuation Tribunal Service
- David Holland, Partner, Squire Patton Boggs (UK) LLP
- John Sayer, Head of Development Consultancy, Ardent; RICS Mediator & Expert Determiner (Global President's Panel); Past Chair of The CPA
- Tom Aslin, Partner, Moore Kingston Smith LLP
- Danni Drummond-Brassington, CEDR and CMC Accredited Mediator, Real Estate Resolve
- Tony Chase FRICS, Consultant, Newmark
- Rebecca Clutten, Barrister, Francis Taylor Building
- Frances Edwards, Senior Associate, Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP
- Paul Sanderson JP LLB (Hons) FRICS FIRRV, President, International Property Tax Institute
- Donald Scannell, Registrar, The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)
- Lucy Thomas, Partner, Bevan Brittan LLP
- Henry Church MRICS, Senior Director, CBRE
- Jacqueline Lean, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Nikita Sellers, Senior Associate, Town Legal LLP
- Marcus Barclay, Partner, CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP
- Karl List BSc (Hons) MRICS Dip Rating, Complex Appeals and Case Manager, HMRC Valuation Office
- Philip Emerick, Senior Rating Director, Ryan Property Tax
- Mr Justice Edwin Johnson, President of the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)
Programme
Module 1
The Art of Gathering and Weighing Evidence: Whether in Court, at Work or Making Everyday Decisions
This event ran on 26 March 2026. Buy and watch the recording here
Sessions Covered:
- Decision making Bias
- Being an Expert - A View from the Bench
- Panel Discussion - How we Weight Evidence
Module 2
Rules, Roles and Responsibilities: Navigating the Transition to Expert Witness
This event ran on 13 April 2026. Buy and watch the recording here
Sessions Covered:
- Legal Framework: CPR Part 35, Tribunal Rules and Practice Directions
- What Makes a Good Expert Tips and Traps
- Transition from a Negotiator to an Expert
- Managing Clients and their Expectations
Module 3a
Rating in the Valuation Tribunal
This event ran on 11 May 2026. Buy and watch the recording here
Sessions Covered:
- Valuation Tribunal vs Upper Tribunal: What Actually Changes?
- Evidence & Persuasion in the Valuation Tribunal
- Running the Case: Tactics, Traps and Settlement
~~
Module 3b
The Duty for the Parties to Mediate in CPO Disputes
This event ran on 18 May 2026. Buy and watch the recording here
Sessions Covered:
- ADR in the CPO World
- When to use ADR? Discussion and Example Decisions re Reasonable Conduct
- Overview of a Typical Mediation
- The Role of the Mediator and Types of Mediation
- Securing a Mediator
- The Role of Professional Advisors
- Preparation Ahead of Mediation
- On the Day
- Outcomes
Module 4
Writing Expert Reports: Clarity, Credibility and Compliance in Expert Evidence
This event ran on 8 June 2026. Buy and watch the recording here
Sessions Covered:
- The Legal and Procedural Framework
- The Expectation of Authorship
- Supporting the Expert: The Role of the Wider Team
- Expert Statements
- Structuring a Clear and Persuasive Expert Report
- Supplemental Reports
- The Relationship Between Written and Oral Evidence
- Panel Discussion: Common Pitfalls in Expert Reporting
Module 5
Practice Directions: Narrowing the Issues to Encourage Early Settlement
This event ran on Monday 29 June. Buy and watch the recording here
Sessions Covered:
- Deep Dive into the Tribunal’s Practice Directions
- What does The Tribunal Want to See from the Parties?
- Expert Joint Statement
- Reviewing External Influences
- Deal Making for an Early Settlement: During this Process
- What Might the Tribunal Think of your Endeavours
Module 6
The Hearing and Lessons from the Front Line: What to Expect and How to Perform at the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)
Monday 13 July l In Person Event, CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP, London
Registration 10:00 l Start 10:30 l Finish 16:30. This event will be followed by a Drinks Reception
Part 1 - In the Heat of the Court Room
This session prepares participants for the structure, pace and expectations of a Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) hearing. It covers the key stages of proceedings and offers practical guidance on giving oral evidence with clarity, confidence and composure. We’ll use a sequence of short sketches of structured mini-hearing scenarios to illustrate different expert witness challenges in cross-examination.
This session prepares participants for the structure, pace and expectations of a Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) hearing. It covers the key stages of proceedings and offers practical guidance on giving oral evidence with clarity, confidence and composure. Attendees will learn how to handle cross-examination, respond effectively to challenges and remain focused under pressure.
Programme:
- The structure of a Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) hearing: what to expect?
- Giving oral evidence: clarity, confidence and composure
- Handling cross-examination and challenges to your evidence
- Observing Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) case law and procedural best practices
- Purdah rules
Part 2 - Best Practice and What Can go Wrong: It is Better to Learn from Others Mistakes than your Own
Panel discussion telling war stories and reflections on hard-earned lessons from experts, solicitors and barristers in a candid discussion about what can go wrong in expert witness work.
- Common errors made by expert witnesses (in reports and oral evidence)
- Case law examples of poor expert evidence and their consequences
- How to maintain credibility and avoid being discredited
- Dealing with conflicting expert opinions
- Continuous professional development and staying updated on Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) trends
Current Speakers:
- Dan Kolinsky KC, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Luke Wilcox, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Jacqueline Lean, Barrister, Landmark Chambers
- Nikita Sellers, Senior Associate, Town Legal LLP
- Marcus Barclay, Partner, CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP
- Colin Cottage BSc (Hons) MRICS RICS Registered Valuer, Managing Director - Compensation, Ardent
- Tony Chase FRICS, Consultant, Newmark
- Paul Sanderson JP LLB (Hons) FRICS FIRRV, President, International Property Tax Institute
- Karl List BSc (Hons) MRICS Dip Rating, Complex Appeals and Case Manager, HMRC Valuation Office
- Philip Emerick, Senior Rating Director, Ryan Property Tax
- Mr Justice Edwin Johnson, President of the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber)